Question Breakdown
The question has three components. First, it invites reflection on the ambiguity of labelling individuals or groups as terrorists or freedom fighters based on political perspectives. Second, it requires a detailed examination of the causes that give rise to terrorism in the modern world. Finally, it calls for a careful differentiation between the Islamic concept of Jihad and acts of terrorism, using religious, ethical, and historical arguments. A comprehensive answer must be rooted in Islamic teachings while being critically aware of modern political narratives.
Outline
- Introduction
- Understanding the Phrase “One Man’s Terrorist is Another Man’s Freedom Fighter”
- Causes of Terrorism
- Political oppression and foreign occupation
- Economic disparity and social injustice
- Religious misinterpretation and radicalization
- Foreign interference and double standards
- Media portrayal and Islamophobia
- Definition and Purpose of Jihad in Islam
- Literal and Shariah-based meaning
- Types of Jihad
- Rules and ethics of Jihad
- Definition and Nature of Terrorism
- Random violence and the killing of innocents
- Absence of an ethical framework and accountability
- Key Differences Between Jihad and Terrorism
- Quranic and Prophetic Teachings Against Terrorism
- Examples of Jihad in Islamic History
- Modern Misuse of Jihad by Extremist Groups
- The Role of Media and Western Hypocrisy
- Solution: Reclaiming the True Meaning of Jihad
- Conclusion
Follow Cssprepforum WhatsApp Channel: Pakistan’s Largest CSS, PMS Prep Community updated
Led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Cssprepforum helps 70,000+ aspirants monthly with top-tier CSS/PMS content. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for solved past papers, expert articles, and free study resources shared by qualifiers and high scorers.
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The 21st century has witnessed an intensification of global conflicts and the rise of terrorism in various regions, often involving Muslim-majority countries. In this environment, the line between legitimate resistance and terrorism has become blurred, especially due to political and media-driven narratives. The phrase “one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter” illustrates the subjective nature of how violence is labelled and interpreted. While Islam recognizes the right to resist injustice through moral and, under strict rules, military means, it categorically forbids the killing of innocent lives and acts of indiscriminate violence. The Islamic concept of Jihad must therefore be separated from modern-day terrorism, both in theory and practice.
Understanding the Phrase “One Man’s Terrorist is Another Man’s Freedom Fighter”
This statement reflects the reality that different groups view violent resistance through differing lenses. For instance, Western powers may label Palestinian resistance as terrorism, while many in the Muslim world see it as a legitimate struggle against occupation. This ambiguity often stems from political biases and a failure to apply consistent ethical standards. The issue becomes more critical when Islam and Muslims are disproportionately associated with violence, without due consideration of context, motive, or religious injunctions.
Causes of Terrorism
a. Political Oppression and Foreign Occupation
When people are denied basic rights and subjected to tyranny or foreign military occupation, frustration can lead to violent outbursts. The ongoing conflicts in Palestine, Kashmir, and Iraq have given rise to resistance groups, some of which adopt violent means due to systemic oppression and a lack of global support.
b. Economic Disparity and Social Injustice
Poverty, unemployment, and social exclusion create fertile ground for extremist recruitment. Many disenfranchised youth, with no access to education or opportunity, fall prey to radical ideologies that offer them identity and purpose.
c. Religious Misinterpretation and Radicalization
Extremist groups distort Islamic texts to justify their actions. Young Muslims who lack proper religious guidance are manipulated into believing that acts of terror serve the cause of Islam, even though the Qur’an and Sunnah strictly condemn such actions.
d. Foreign Interference and Double Standards
Global powers often intervene militarily in Muslim countries, supporting dictatorships or backing invasions, leading to resentment and violent backlash. The double standards in supporting democracy at home while suppressing it abroad add to the feeling of injustice.
e. Media Portrayal and Islamophobia
Mainstream media often reinforces stereotypes by labelling Muslims as terrorists while ignoring the root causes of conflict. Islamophobia has further alienated Muslim communities and contributed to the rise of identity-based extremism.
3.5-Month Extensive Compulsory Subjects Course for CSS Aspirants
Struggling with CSS Compulsory subjects? Crack Pakistan Affairs, Islamiat, GSA & Current Affairs in just 3.5 months with Howfiv’s expert-led course. New batches every April, August & December! Secure your spot now – WhatsApp 0300-6322446!
Definition and Purpose of Jihad in Islam
a. Literal and Shariah-Based Meaning
The word jihad comes from the Arabic root jahada, meaning “to strive” or “to struggle.” In Islam, jihad refers to striving in the path of Allah through both non-violent and, when necessary, armed means to uphold justice.
b. Types of Jihad
- Jihad al-Nafs: Struggle against one’s inner desires and sins.
- Jihad bil-Ilm: Striving through knowledge and education.
- Jihad bil-Mal: Spending in the way of Allah.
- Jihad bil-Saif: Armed struggle under strict ethical conditions.
c. Rules and Ethics of Jihad
Islamic law governs Jihad with clear conditions:
- Must be declared by a legitimate authority
- Innocents, including women, children, and non-combatants, must not be harmed
- Environmental destruction and torture are prohibited
- The enemy must be treated with dignity
- Peace is preferable if the enemy inclines toward it
As Allah says, “Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not like transgressors.” (Surah Al-Baqarah, 2:190)
Definition and Nature of Terrorism
Terrorism refers to the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in pursuit of political or ideological goals. It disregards morality and accountability and often involves indiscriminate killing, bombings, and suicide attacks targeting innocent people. As Allah says, “Whoever kills a person [unjustly]… it is as if he had slain mankind entirely.” (Surah Al-Ma’idah, 5:32)
Islamic teachings are in direct contradiction to such acts.
Key Differences Between Jihad and Terrorism
| Criteria | Jihad (in Islam) | Terrorism |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Justice, defense, ending oppression | Chaos, fear, political revenge |
| Conduct | Regulated by ethics and Shariah | No rules or accountability |
| Target | Combatants only | Often civilians and non-combatants |
| Authority | Declared by a state or Imam | Initiated by individuals/groups |
| Outcome Desired | Peace, reformation | Instability, media attention |
Quranic and Prophetic Teachings Against Terrorism
The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) strictly forbade harming civilians, animals, and even trees during warfare. He condemned treachery and betrayal. During the conquest of Makkah, he declared general amnesty for all despite decades of hostility. He PBUH says, “Do not kill any child, any woman, or any elder or sick person…” (Sunan Abu Dawud). Such hadiths show that Islamic warfare is not aimed at vengeance but justice.
Examples of Jihad in Islamic History
- Battle of Badr: A defensive battle fought under strict divine commands.
- Salahuddin Ayyubi: Treated prisoners of war with dignity after liberating Jerusalem.
- Ottoman Resistance: Resisted colonial aggression with clear moral boundaries.
These historical figures engaged in legitimate Jihad while upholding Islamic ethics.
Modern Misuse of Jihad by Extremist Groups
Groups such as Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and others have hijacked the term jihad to justify political violence. They violate every principle of Islamic warfare, including killing Muslims, women, and children. Their actions serve geopolitical agendas rather than Islamic objectives.
The Role of Media and Western Hypocrisy
The media often equates all Islamic resistance with terrorism while ignoring state-sponsored violence by Western powers. Drone strikes, economic sanctions, and military invasions are rarely called terrorism, although they result in mass civilian casualties.
Solution: Reclaiming the True Meaning of Jihad
- Islamic scholars must clarify the true teachings of Jihad through sermons, writings, and educational efforts.
- Muslim governments should counter extremism through justice, reform, and transparency.
- Educational curricula should include authentic Islamic perspectives on peace, justice, and resistance.
- Youth should be empowered intellectually and spiritually to resist radical narratives.
Conclusion
While terrorism and Jihad are often confused in public discourse, they are fundamentally different in origin, ethics, and goals. Islam commands its followers to resist oppression through lawful and moral means, not through indiscriminate violence and terror. The Qur’an and Sunnah offer a complete framework for peace, justice, and legitimate defense. Understanding this distinction is essential for Muslims and non-Muslims alike to prevent the manipulation of Islamic values and foster a more just global order. The Muslim Ummah must reclaim the noble concept of Jihad and separate it firmly from acts of terror falsely committed in its name.
