Question Breakdown
This question is divided into three interrelated components. Firstly, it inquires whether Ijtihad is still a practical and applicable tool in the modern age. This requires examining the historical and contemporary use of Ijtihad and its potential role in modern society. Secondly, the question seeks a detailed description of the conditions or qualifications necessary for a person to be considered a Mujtahid. Lastly, it asks whether a learned Muslim can rightfully engage in Ijtihad and what legal, social, and theological consequences may arise from such efforts. Each part must be addressed with references from Islamic jurisprudence, Qur’an, Sunnah, and scholarly opinions.
Outline
- Introduction
- Understanding Ijtihad: Definition and Scope
- Historical Development of Ijtihad
- Is Ijtihad No Longer Practical Today?
a. Arguments against its practicality
b. Arguments in favor of its continued relevance - Role of Ijtihad in the Modern World
- Conditions for a Mujtahid
- Rights of a Learned Muslim to Perform Ijtihad
- Consequences of Ijtihad by a Competent Scholar
- Collective Ijtihad: A Contemporary Model
- Conclusion
Follow Cssprepforum WhatsApp Channel: Pakistan’s Largest CSS, PMS Prep Community updated
Led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Cssprepforum helps 70,000+ aspirants monthly with top-tier CSS/PMS content. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for solved past papers, expert articles, and free study resources shared by qualifiers and high scorers.
Answer to the Question
Introduction
Islamic jurisprudence (Fiqh) has always relied on two fundamental mechanisms: Taqlid (imitation of precedent) and Ijtihad (independent reasoning). Among these, Ijtihad has been the dynamic force allowing Islamic law to respond to new realities across centuries. As the world faces unprecedented challenges ranging from bioethics to digital economies, the question arises whether Ijtihad remains a practical tool in modern times. This answer seeks to explore the continuing relevance of Ijtihad, the qualifications of a Mujtahid, and the permissibility and consequences of a learned Muslim engaging in Ijtihad.
Understanding Ijtihad: Definition and Scope
The word Ijtihad is derived from the Arabic root jahada, which means "to strive" or "to exert effort." In legal terminology, it refers to the exertion of a jurist’s intellectual faculties to derive legal rulings from the Qur’an and Sunnah in cases where direct textual evidence is absent.
Imam Al-Ghazali defines Ijtihad as “exerting one’s utmost effort to arrive at a judgment in a matter that is not explicitly stated in the Qur’an or Sunnah.”
It covers a wide range of issues, including new technological advancements, ethical dilemmas, social reforms, and financial regulations that were not present during the early Islamic era.
Historical Development of Ijtihad
During the time of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), legal guidance came directly from divine revelation. After his death, the Companions (Sahabah) used their reasoning to address emerging issues. For example, Caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab practised Ijtihad when he suspended the punishment of theft during famine, despite its fixed ruling in the Qur’an (Surah Al-Ma’idah, 5:38).
Over time, schools of Islamic jurisprudence (Madhahib) developed, and jurists like Abu Hanifa, Malik, Shafi’i, and Ahmad ibn Hanbal institutionalized Ijtihad. However, from the 10th century onward, many scholars declared the "closure of the gate of Ijtihad," fearing legal chaos, and encouraged Taqlid instead.
Is Ijtihad No Longer Practical Today?
a. Arguments Against Its Practicality
Some scholars argue that Ijtihad has become impractical due to:
- The complexity of modern life requires expertise across multiple disciplines
- The lack of scholars with the intellectual depth and linguistic mastery of classical Mujtahids
- Fear of misinterpretation and deviation from Shariah principles
- The rise of unqualified individuals issuing fatwas in the name of Ijtihad
These concerns have led to a conservative approach where taqlid dominates in many parts of the Muslim world.
b. Arguments in Favour of Its Continued Relevance
On the contrary, many contemporary scholars argue that Ijtihad is more necessary than ever due to:
- Emerging issues like organ transplantation, cybercrime, artificial intelligence, and gender ethics
- The need for Islamization of modern legal systems
- The Qur’an’s emphasis on using intellect, “Will you not then reflect?” (Surah Al-A’raf, 7:176). Moreover, “Ask the people of knowledge if you do not know.” (Surah An-Nahl, 16:43)
- The precedent of Ijtihad used by the Prophet’s companions after his death
Therefore, Ijtihad remains not only practical but essential for preserving the dynamism and relevance of Islamic law in contemporary society.
Role of Ijtihad in the Modern World
In the modern context, Ijtihad serves various functions:
- Legal reform: Revisiting outdated rulings in light of new realities
- Social justice: Ensuring gender equity, minority rights, and economic fairness
- Technological ethics: Addressing issues like surrogacy, cloning, and digital currency
- Global interaction: Enabling Muslims to adapt Shariah principles in pluralistic societies
Institutions like the Islamic Fiqh Academy and Al-Azhar University are actively engaged in collective Ijtihad to resolve contemporary issues.
Conditions for a Mujtahid
Islamic tradition lays down rigorous conditions for one to qualify as a Mujtahid:
- Mastery of the Arabic language: to understand the Qur’an and Hadith directly
- Deep knowledge of the Qur’an: including Nasikh and Mansukh (abrogated verses)
- Expertise in Hadith sciences: authenticity, context, and interpretation
- Knowledge of Ijma and Qiyas: consensus and analogical reasoning
- Awareness of the objectives of Shariah (Maqasid al-Shariah)
- Taqwa and integrity: moral uprightness and fear of Allah
- Intellectual ability to reason independently
These stringent requirements ensure that only those truly qualified may engage in Ijtihad, preventing misuse and chaos in legal rulings.
CSS Solved Islamiat Past Papers from 2010 to Date by Miss Ayesha Irfan
Gain unmatched conceptual clarity with CSS Solved Islamiat (2010 – To Date) by Miss Ayesha Irfan, the definitive guide to mastering Islamiat for CSS with precision, insight, and unwavering confidence!
Rights of a Learned Muslim to Perform Ijtihad
The right to perform Ijtihad is not limited to medieval scholars. If a learned Muslim today meets the qualifications of a Mujtahid, he or she may perform Ijtihad. Scholars like Shah Waliullah Dehlawi and Muhammad Iqbal strongly advocated for reviving Ijtihad to address modern realities. “The teaching of the Qur’an that life is a process of progressive creation necessitates that each generation must be equipped with tools of Ijtihad.” According to Allama Iqbal. Islamic jurisprudence acknowledges that in the absence of a single Mujtahid with all qualifications, collective Ijtihad through juristic bodies can be pursued.
Consequences of Ijtihad by a Competent Scholar
When a qualified Mujtahid performs Ijtihad:
- If correct, he is rewarded twice
- If mistaken, he is rewarded once
This shows the flexibility and encouragement Islam provides for sincere scholarly effort.
However, if an unqualified person issues rulings without proper knowledge, it can lead to:
- Misinterpretation of Shariah
- Sectarian conflict
- Legal anarchy
Thus, Ijtihad must be regulated by scholarly institutions and supervised by consensus.
Collective Ijtihad: A Contemporary Model
Given the complexity of modern problems, collective Ijtihad (Ijtihad Jama’i) is gaining popularity. It involves a group of scholars with expertise in different areas, such as Fiqh, medicine, economics, and science, collaborating to issue rulings on complex issues.
For example, the International Islamic Fiqh Academy (OIC) regularly gathers scholars to discuss global challenges and issue contemporary fatwas. This model ensures both scholarly rigor and practical applicability.
Conclusion
Ijtihad is not only practical but essential in the present age. It allows Islamic jurisprudence to evolve responsibly, offering solutions to new problems while staying rooted in divine guidance. While the conditions for a Mujtahid are strict, they are not impossible to meet. A learned Muslim who fulfills these requirements does have the right to engage in Ijtihad. However, to preserve the integrity of Islamic law, such efforts must be backed by deep knowledge, institutional support, and accountability. In a time of rapid change, Ijtihad remains the bridge between timeless principles and modern realities.
