Question Breakdown
This question focuses on the concept of Motahida Qaumiyat (United Nationalism or Pan-Islamism), which emphasizes the unity of the Muslim Ummah beyond ethnic, linguistic, or national boundaries. The examiner expects a twofold answer: first, an explanation of the ideology itself in the context of Muslim identity, and second, a detailed account of how two visionary Muslim thinkers, Jamaluddin Afghani and Allama Muhammad Iqbal, contributed to advancing this concept through their political activism, philosophical writings, and calls for Islamic revivalism. Historical context, philosophical insight, and examples from their lives and writings should be used to support the answer.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-Understanding Motahida Qaumiyat
3-Jamaluddin Afghani: The Father of Pan-Islamism
4-Afghani’s Philosophical Contributions
- Rejection of sectarianism and regionalism
- Promotion of rationalism and reformist thought
- Influence on later reformers, including Iqbal
5-Allama Iqbal: The Philosopher of Muslim Renaissance
- Iqbal’s concept of the Muslim Ummah
- Critique of nationalism and Western imperialism
- Vision of a united Islamic polity in his poetry and lectures
6-Iqbal’s Practical Steps Toward Motahida Qaumiyat
- Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam
- Address to the Muslim League (1930)
- Support for the idea of a separate homeland as a center of Islamic revival
7-Comparison of Afghani and Iqbal’s Approaches
- Afghani: activist and agitator
- Iqbal: philosopher and ideological guide
- Shared commitment to Islamic solidarity
8-Contemporary Relevance of Motahida Qaumiyat
9-Conclusion
Follow Cssprepforum WhatsApp Channel: Pakistan’s Largest CSS, PMS Prep Community updated
Led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Cssprepforum helps 70,000+ aspirants monthly with top-tier CSS/PMS content. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for solved past papers, expert articles, and free study resources shared by qualifiers and high scorers.
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The term Motahida Qaumiyat refers to the ideology of a united Muslim identity that transcends geographical, ethnic, and political boundaries. It envisions the Muslim Ummah as a single spiritual and socio-political entity bound by the values of Islam, rather than by nationalism or state boundaries. This ideal gained momentum during the decline of Muslim empires and the rise of Western colonialism, which divided the Muslim world into isolated and often hostile nation-states. Two towering figures who championed this vision of unity were Jamaluddin Afghani and Allama Muhammad Iqbal. Through their political activism and philosophical thought, they laid the groundwork for Islamic solidarity in the modern era.
Understanding Motahida Qaumiyat
Motahida Qaumiyat, or Pan-Islamism, rejects the concept of territorial nationalism in favour of the Ummah, the global Muslim community. According to this vision, all Muslims, regardless of race, nationality, or sect, are part of a single nation (Qaum) guided by shared religious and ethical principles. The Qur’an says, “Indeed, this Ummah of yours is one Ummah, and I am your Lord, so worship Me.”(Surah Al-Anbiya, 21:92) This concept emerged as a powerful response to the colonial strategy of "divide and rule" and aimed to unify the Muslim world politically, economically, and spiritually.
Jamaluddin Afghani: The Father of Pan-Islamism
Jamaluddin Afghani (1838–1897) is regarded as the earliest modern proponent of Pan-Islamism. Born in Persia and active across South Asia and the Middle East, Afghani traveled extensively to awaken the Muslim consciousness. He believed that the decline of the Muslim world was due to disunity, sectarianism, and intellectual stagnation. Afghani tirelessly advocated for Muslim unity to resist Western imperialism and reestablish Islamic sovereignty.
Afghani’s activism extended to Egypt, India, Turkey, and Iran. He urged Muslim rulers and intellectuals to establish alliances and modernize their societies through science, education, and political reform. He considered the revival of Ijtihad (independent reasoning) essential for resisting colonial dominance.
Afghani’s Philosophical Contributions
Afghani emphasized the role of reason and science in Islamic thought. He argued that Islam was never against modern knowledge and that Muslims must reclaim their scientific legacy. His efforts were not limited to politics; they also targeted reforming religious thought and defeating fatalism among Muslims. Afghani’s lectures and writings laid the intellectual foundations for later thinkers, especially Allama Iqbal, who admired his boldness and clarity.
Allama Iqbal: The Philosopher of Muslim Renaissance
Allama Muhammad Iqbal (1877–1938), the poet-philosopher of the East, gave Pan-Islamism a philosophical depth and spiritual soul. Deeply disturbed by the spiritual and political decline of Muslims, Iqbal believed that only a reconstruction of Muslim identity rooted in Tawheed, Khudi (selfhood), and collective unity could reverse their downfall. He famously declared, “Nations are born in the hearts of poets; they prosper and die in the hands of politicians.” Iqbal envisioned the Muslim Ummah as a dynamic spiritual brotherhood, not confined by borders or race. He rejected racial nationalism as a destructive force and viewed Islam as the only viable alternative for a united and just civilization.
CSS Solved Islamiat Past Papers from 2010 to Date by Miss Ayesha Irfan
Gain unmatched conceptual clarity with CSS Solved Islamiat (2010 – To Date) by Miss Ayesha Irfan, the definitive guide to mastering Islamiat for CSS with precision, insight, and unwavering confidence!
Iqbal’s Practical Steps Toward Motahida Qaumiyat
In his poetry and philosophical works like “Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam,” Iqbal laid out the intellectual foundations of a Pan-Islamic polity. His 1930 Allahabad Address called for the establishment of a separate Muslim homeland in the Indian subcontinent as a spiritual and political center for Islamic revival. Though not identical to Afghani’s call for a unified Caliphate, Iqbal’s goal was the same: to unite Muslims under a common ideological and moral order.
Comparison of Afghani and Iqbal’s Approaches
While Jamaluddin Afghani operated as a revolutionary political activist, Iqbal played the role of a philosophical guide and visionary poet. Afghani mobilized rulers and intellectuals against colonialism; Iqbal sought to reform the Muslim psyche and ideology. Both, however, shared a deep commitment to Islamic revivalism, the unity of the Ummah, and the rejection of secular nationalism.
Contemporary Relevance of Motahida Qaumiyat
Today, the Muslim world is fragmented by ethnic rivalries, sectarian violence, and geopolitical divides. The dream of Motahida Qaumiyat appears distant but remains relevant. The teachings of Afghani and Iqbal remind us that without spiritual unity, ethical governance, and intellectual reform, the Muslim Ummah cannot reclaim its lost status. A return to their vision may pave the way for genuine solidarity and cooperation among Muslim nations.
Conclusion
Motahida Qaumiyat is not just a political dream; it is a spiritual and intellectual imperative rooted in Islamic teachings. Jamaluddin Afghani and Allama Iqbal were pioneers who gave voice and vision to this ideal. In an age of disunity and moral confusion, their message of unity, revival, and purposeful identity remains a guiding light for the Muslim world.
