Introduction
Islam, as a comprehensive and all-encompassing code of life, provides extensive guidance that extends far beyond an individual's personal and spiritual development. Its teachings are intricately woven into the fabric of society, offering a complete framework for social, economic, and political harmony. Central to this framework are the foundational principles of governance, administration, and public service. In an era increasingly defined by complex bureaucratic structures, multi-layered hierarchies, and the vast machinery of the modern state, the role of the civil servant has become not just important but absolutely crucial. As the primary interface between the state and its populace, civil servants are instrumental in ensuring the effective functioning of the government and the equitable, efficient delivery of essential services to every citizen. Their position as stewards of public trust is paramount to maintaining social order and fostering a prosperous society. As such, this article seeks to explore the responsibilities of civil servants through an Islamic lens, drawing upon the foundational sources of the Qur’an, Sunnah, and the practices of the Rightly Guided Caliphs. It argues that the Islamic framework for public service is built upon a robust moral and ethical foundation that is deeply rooted in a divine mandate. This foundation provides an uncompromising guide for public officials, emphasizing that justice (Adl) is not merely a legal or procedural concept but a divine command to be applied without favour, that accountability (Mas'uliyah) is a sacred duty to be answered for before God and the people, and that the welfare of all people, regardless of their faith or status, is the ultimate goal of governance. By examining these principles, a clear and effective model for public administration can be established that is not only historically rich but also profoundly relevant to the challenges faced by modern states, particularly in the context of the civil service in Pakistan.
Follow CPF WhatsApp Channel for Daily Exam Updates
Cssprepforum, led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, supports 70,000+ monthly aspirants with premium CSS/PMS prep. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for daily CSS/PMS updates, solved past papers, expert articles, and free prep resources.
A Comparative Lens: The Civil Servant in Modern and Islamic Thought
To understand the Islamic perspective, it is first necessary to define what a civil servant is in the modern sense and then contextualize this role within Islamic and Pakistani frameworks.
The Modern Concept of a Civil Servant
In modern political science and public administration, a civil servant is an individual employed in the public sector by a government department or agency. They are part of the permanent executive branch of a state, serving the government of the day regardless of political changes. Their primary function is to implement public policy and deliver public services impartially and efficiently. A bureaucratic structure, a hierarchical chain of command, and a focus on procedural rules and regulations typically characterize this role. The core values of a modern civil servant often include neutrality, impartiality, integrity, and efficiency. However, the modern concept, rooted in Western thought, often struggles with a definitive moral compass, leading to issues like corruption and red tape.
The Islamic Concept: Amanah and Mas'uliyah
Islam, while not having a term equivalent to "civil servant" in its classical sources, establishes the role of a public official through the concepts of Amanah (trust) and Mas'uliyah (responsibility or accountability). A public servant, in the Islamic view, is an individual entrusted by God and the people to carry out a specific duty. The position of authority is not a privilege to be exploited but a sacred trust for which one will be held accountable.
To start with, Amanah signifies the idea that authority, wealth, and power are not one's own but a trust from Allah. The Qur’an states: “Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due; and when you judge between people to judge with justice” (An-Nisa 4:58). This verse is a foundational text for all forms of public administration in Islam, asserting that a position of power is a divine trust that must be executed with justice.
Moreover, Mas'uliyah, meaning responsibility, is the logical extension of Amanah. Every individual, particularly a public servant, is responsible for their actions. This responsibility is dual: to God and to the people they serve. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasized this in a famous Hadith, stating: “Each of you is a shepherd and each of you is responsible for his flock” (Sunan Abu Dawood: 2928). This metaphor powerfully encapsulates the idea that a ruler or an administrator is a caretaker, not an owner, of the public trust and will be questioned about their caretaking.
The Civil Service in Pakistan: A Brief Overview
The civil service in Pakistan has its roots in the British colonial administration, particularly the Indian Civil Service (ICS). This legacy has resulted in a hierarchical and elite-oriented bureaucratic structure. While the system was originally designed to maintain order and revenue collection, it has since evolved to include development and public service delivery. The challenges faced by Pakistan's civil service today, such as corruption, political interference, inefficiency, and a general lack of public trust, highlight a critical need for a renewed ethical and moral framework. Re-examining the role of a civil servant through the lens of Islamic principles can provide a powerful antidote to these contemporary ailments, offering a clear roadmap for reform and good governance.
CSS Solved Islamiat Past Papers from 2010 to Date by Miss Ayesha Irfan
Gain unmatched conceptual clarity with CSS Solved Islamiat (2010 – To Date) by Miss Ayesha Irfan, the definitive guide to mastering Islamiat for CSS with precision, insight, and unwavering confidence!
Core Principles of Governance in Islam
The responsibilities of civil servants in Islam are not isolated duties but are derived from a set of foundational principles that govern the entire political and administrative system. These principles form the ethical and moral bedrock of an Islamic state and are essential for understanding the role of a public servant.
Justice (Adl)
Justice is the cornerstone of Islamic governance. It is not merely the absence of injustice but a proactive principle requiring the equitable distribution of rights, responsibilities, and resources. Justice is a divine attribute, and human rulers and administrators are required to reflect this attribute in their conduct. The Qur’an repeatedly emphasizes the importance of justice, even in the most difficult circumstances. It commands believers: “O you who have believed, be persistently firm in justice, witnesses for Allah, even if it be against yourselves or parents and relatives…” (Qur’an, An-Nisa 4:135). For a civil servant, this means that their decisions must be based on fairness, impartiality, and the rule of law, regardless of the social status, wealth, or faith of the individuals involved.
Trust (Amanah)
As previously discussed, the concept of Amanah is central to the Islamic view of public office. Any position of power, from a high-ranking official to a village administrator, is a trust from Allah. This trust extends to public resources, authority, and the welfare of the people. The civil servant is merely a trustee, and any misuse of this trust is a grave sin. The Holy Prophet (PBUH) cautioned against seeking positions of authority, stating, "O 'Abdur-Rahman! Do not seek to be a ruler, for if you are given authority on your demand, then you will be held responsible for it, but if you are given it without asking for it, then you will be helped (by Allah) in it." (Sahih al-Bukhari 7146), underscoring the gravity of this principle. It instils in the civil servant a profound sense of responsibility beyond their immediate superiors and the political system.
Accountability (Mas'uliyah)
Accountability in Islam is not limited to a legal or administrative review; it is a moral and spiritual imperative. A civil servant is accountable to three parties: Allah, the people, and the state. First, accountability to Allah is the most significant, as it entails answering for one's actions on the Day of Judgment. This belief serves as a powerful deterrent against corruption and malpractice. Second, accountability to the people means that public servants must be transparent, accessible, and responsive to the needs of the citizens. The historical practice of Hisbah, a system of public inspection and supervision, ensured that public officials adhered to ethical standards and performed their duties diligently. The final layer is accountability to the state's legal and administrative framework.
Consultation (Shura)
Shura, or consultation, is a fundamental principle of Islamic governance. The Qur’an commands the Prophet (PBUH) and, by extension, all Muslims in positions of authority, to consult with their people: “…Consult with them about matters, then, when you have decided on a course of action, put your trust in God…” (Ali ‘Imran 3:159). This principle emphasizes a participatory approach to governance, where decisions are not made autocratically but through discussion and deliberation. For civil servants, this means that they should not act in isolation but should seek advice and consider the perspectives of their colleagues, subordinates, and, most importantly, the people who will be affected by their decisions. This fosters an environment of inclusion and ensures that policies are well-informed and widely accepted.
Key Responsibilities of Civil Servants
Rooted in these core principles, the following are the key responsibilities that define the role of a civil servant in Islam.
Adhering to the Qur’an and Sunnah
The paramount responsibility of a civil servant in an Islamic framework is to ensure that all their actions, policies, and decisions are in accordance with the divine law as revealed in the Qur’an and the prophetic practice (Sunnah) of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). This is the ultimate source of authority and morality for all Muslims. Every other responsibility, from upholding justice to protecting citizens' rights, is derived from and subordinate to this foundational duty. A civil servant's ultimate allegiance is to Allah, and the Shariah provides the unyielding standard by which their performance is measured. This principle ensures that the public service remains firmly grounded in a divine moral code, preventing it from being swayed by transient political interests or personal whims. The first and foremost loyalty is to the divine mandate, which then governs their conduct toward the state and its people.
For instance, the Qur’an explicitly establishes the hierarchy of authority for believers. It states: “O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you.” (An-Nisa 4:59). This verse sets the clear precedent that the authority of a public official is not absolute but is conditional on their obedience to Allah and His Messenger. A civil servant, therefore, must always ensure that their actions align with Islamic teachings. If an order from a superior or a policy of the government contradicts the Qur’an or Sunnah, the civil servant's first duty is to the divine law.
Upholding Justice (Adl) and Fairness
The foremost duty of any public official is to dispense justice impartially. A civil servant must ensure that all their actions and decisions are fair and do not discriminate based on race, religion, social status, or political affiliation. This is a direct command from the Qur’an, which states: “O you who have believed, be persistently firm for Allah, witnesses in justice, and do not let the hatred of a people prevent you from being just. Be just; that is nearer to righteousness” (Al-Ma’idah 5:8).
The most powerful example of this principle is the case of the noblewoman from the Makhzumi tribe who was convicted of theft during the time of the Prophet (PBUH). Her family, fearing the shame of a public punishment, pleaded with a respected companion, Usama ibn Zaid, to intercede with the Prophet. When Usama conveyed their request, the Prophet became angry and gave a powerful sermon, saying: “The people before you were destroyed because when a noble person among them stole, they would let him go, and when a poor person among them stole, they would inflict the punishment upon him. By Allah, if Fatima, the daughter of Muhammad, were to steal, I would cut off her hand.” (Sahih al-Bukhari: 8787). This incident demonstrates that justice in Islam is absolute and applies equally to everyone, regardless of their family lineage or social standing. A civil servant must embody this principle by ensuring that the law is applied without fear or Favor.
Maintaining Honesty and Integrity (Amanah)
A civil servant is a trustee of public office and public funds. Honesty and integrity are therefore non-negotiable qualities. This includes not only refraining from embezzlement and corruption but also being truthful in all dealings, both official and personal. The Prophet (PBUH) said: "The trustworthy, honest treasurer who gives what he is ordered to give fully, willingly, and gladly, to the one to whom he is ordered to give, is one of the two givers of charity" (Sahih al-Bukhari: 2319). This Hadith highlights that a public official who handles the public treasury with honesty is rewarded as if they themselves were giving charity. The principle of Amanah extends to the performance of duties; a civil servant must perform their job diligently and to the best of their ability, as this too is a trust from Allah.
For instance, the Rightly Guided Caliphs, particularly Hazrat Abu Bakr (RA) and Hazrat Umar (RA), provided stellar examples of financial integrity. Hazrat Abu Bakr (RA), upon becoming Caliph, initially continued to work as a merchant to support his family. When his companions insisted that his duties as a Caliph were too great to allow him to continue his trade, he reluctantly agreed to accept a modest stipend from the public treasury, a sum barely enough to meet his family's basic needs (Ibn Sa'd in At-Tabaqat Al-Kubra). This act set a precedent for future rulers and civil servants, emphasizing that a position of power should not be a means for personal enrichment.
Exercising Accountability (Mas'uliyah) to God and the People
Civil servants are accountable for every decision and action they take. This accountability is twofold: to Allah in the hereafter and to the people in this world. This dual accountability ensures that the civil servant acts with a high degree of conscientiousness. The Prophet (PBUH) once said: "All of you are guardians and are responsible for your subjects. The ruler is a guardian over his subjects and is responsible for them…" (Sahih al-Bukhari: 7138). This profound statement elevates the civil servant's role from a mere job to a sacred duty for which they will be questioned.
To illustrate, the caliphate of Hazrat Umar (RA) is a golden age of accountability. He established a system of Hisbah, where officials were appointed to ensure market regulations and public morality. More importantly, he established a rigorous system of personal accountability. He would regularly hold public assemblies where citizens could directly question him or his governors. A famous incident recounts how a citizen questioned him on his cloak and whether it was purchased from the public treasury. Hazrat Umar (RA) calmly explained that it was a personal item, showcasing his commitment to transparency and direct public accountability. He also used to send spies to his governors to ensure they were fulfilling their duties and not abusing their power. He famously dismissed his own son from a position of authority for a minor transgression, proving that accountability was not just a slogan but a deeply ingrained practice.
Ensuring Competence and Meritocracy
Islam stresses the importance of appointing the most capable individuals to positions of authority. Civil servants must be competent and qualified for the jobs they hold. The Qur’an, in the context of appointing a ruler, mentions two key qualities: strength (Qawi) and trustworthiness (Ameen). The story of Prophet Musa (AS) and the appointment of the man to water the flock highlights this: “One of them said, 'O my father, hire him. Indeed, the best one you can hire is the strong and the trustworthy'” (Qur’an, Al-Qasas 28:26). A civil servant must therefore not only be morally upright but also possess the necessary skills and expertise to perform their duties effectively. Meritocracy is the only legitimate basis for appointment and promotion in public service.
For instance, Hazrat Umar (RA) was particularly strict about meritocracy. He was known for appointing his governors based on their administrative ability and piety rather than their tribal connections or family ties. He famously replaced Khalid ibn al-Walid (RA), a celebrated general, with Abu Ubaidah ibn al-Jarrah (RA) not because of any failure on Khalid's part, but because he feared the people would begin to worship Khalid instead of Allah. He made it clear that a public position was a service, not a platform for personal fame. He also held his governors to a high standard, frequently dismissing them if they failed to meet their responsibilities or showed any signs of arrogance.
Serving the Public with Humility and Compassion
The role of a civil servant is to serve the people, not to rule over them. This requires a deep sense of humility and compassion. A public official must view themselves as a servant of the community. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) once said: “The leader of the people is their servant” (Sahih al-Bukhari). This statement reverses the traditional power dynamic, placing the ruler at the service of the ruled. A civil servant must therefore be approachable, kind, and empathetic to the struggles of the common person.
Moreover, the lives of the Rightly Guided Caliphs are filled with examples of humility and compassion. One of the most famous stories is of Hazrat Umar (RA), who, during a period of famine, was seen carrying a heavy sack of flour on his back to a needy family. A companion offered to carry the sack for him, but Hazrat Umar (RA) replied: “Will you carry my burden for me on the Day of Judgment?” He understood his responsibility not as a distant ruler but as a direct servant of his people. This act of profound humility and compassion demonstrates that a civil servant’s duty extends beyond their official functions to the personal well-being of the citizens they serve.
Financial Prudence and Fiscal Transparency
A civil servant is a custodian of public funds. They must manage these funds with the utmost care, avoiding extravagance, waste, and personal use. Every expenditure must be for the benefit of the public. This principle is deeply embedded in the Islamic teachings on wealth and spending. The Qur’an cautions against extravagance: “...and do not be extravagant. Indeed, the wasteful are brothers of the devils, and ever has Satan been to his Lord ungrateful” (Al-Isra 17:26-27). This teaching applies even more so to public funds.
For instance, the Caliphate of Hazrat Umar (RA) was marked by strict fiscal discipline. He refused to use any public funds for personal luxuries and lived an extremely simple life. He also kept a rigorous check on the financial dealings of his governors and officials. He famously ordered that any governor who became excessively wealthy during their term be investigated and, if necessary, have their wealth confiscated and returned to the public treasury. His practice of living a life of austerity while in office served as a powerful example for all public servants that their position was not for personal gain but for the collective good.
Accessibility and Responsiveness to the Public
A civil servant must be accessible and responsive to the people they serve. A barrier between the ruler and the ruled is discouraged in Islam. The Prophet (PBUH) prayed against those who would create such a barrier, saying: “O Allah, whoever is given charge of some affair of my Ummah and treats them with hardship, treat him with hardship. And whoever is given charge of some affair of my Ummah and treats them with kindness, treat him with kindness” (Sahih Muslim: 1828a). This Hadith serves as a powerful reminder that a civil servant's role is to facilitate, not obstruct, the public's access to justice and services.
Moreover, the caliphs of early Islam were known for their open-door policy. Hazrat Umar (RA) would often patrol the streets of Medina at night to hear his people's concerns directly. He believed that the ruler must be the first to know of any suffering in the land. Similarly, Hazrat Ali (RA), in his famous letter to Malik al-Ashtar, his governor in Egypt, instructed him to: “...grant a specific time for those who need you, where you free yourself for them and sit in a public meeting with them. Be humble to them and let your guards and your assistants stay away from you so that they may talk to you without being afraid of anyone” (Nahj al-Balagha). This instruction is a timeless guide for public servants, emphasizing direct engagement and the removal of administrative barriers.
Consultation in Decision-Making (Shura)
While the ultimate decision-making power may rest with the civil servant, it is their responsibility to consult with relevant stakeholders before making significant decisions. The Qur’an commands the Prophet (PBUH) to consult his companions in matters of public affairs, a principle that applies to all administrators. This practice ensures that decisions are well-informed, reflect a diversity of perspectives, and are more likely to be accepted by the public.
To illustrate, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) consistently practiced Shura, even after receiving divine revelation. A famous instance is the Battle of Uhud, where he consulted his companions on whether to fight outside or inside the city walls. Although he personally favoured a defensive strategy, he deferred to the majority opinion of fighting outside the city. While the outcome was not favourable, this incident established the importance of consultation and democratic practice in governance. The Rightly Guided Caliphs institutionalized this practice, forming councils (Shura) to deliberate on all major political, administrative, and military decisions.
Protection of the Rights and Welfare of All Citizens
A civil servant is responsible for the welfare of all citizens, including minorities. The Islamic state is obligated to protect the life, property, and honour of all its inhabitants. This principle is a cornerstone of co-existence in a multi-faith society. The Prophet (PBUH) said: “Beware! Whoever oppresses a Mu’ahid (a non-Muslim citizen of an Islamic state), or curtails his rights, or burdens him with more than he can bear, or takes anything from him against his will, then I am his adversary on the Day of Judgment” (Sunan Abi Dawud 3052). This strong statement guarantees the rights of non-Muslim citizens and warns public officials against any form of discrimination or oppression.
Furthermore, the Caliphate of Hazrat Umar (RA) is replete with examples of protecting minority rights. The Treaty of Jerusalem, signed after the city's conquest, guaranteed the safety of the Christian inhabitants, their churches, and their property. A famous story tells of Hazrat Umar (RA) seeing an old Jewish man begging on the street. When he learned that the man was a non-Muslim citizen and had to beg because he could not pay the tax, Hazrat Umar (RA) immediately exempted him from the tax, provided for his needs from the public treasury, and declared that such treatment was an act of injustice.
Avoiding Nepotism, Favouritism, and Corruption
Nepotism and favouritism, which are forms of corruption, are strictly forbidden in Islam. A civil servant must base their decisions on merit and fairness, not on personal relationships. Appointing a less qualified person to a position of authority because of family ties is a breach of trust. The Prophet (PBUH) said: “If authority is given to someone who is not competent, then wait for the Hour (i.e., the Day of Judgment)” (Sahih al-Bukhari: 6496). This Hadith equates the appointment of an incompetent person to a position of trust with the end of the world, highlighting the immense gravity of the act.
For instance, Hazrat Ali (RA), in his letter to Malik al-Ashtar, provided a timeless piece of advice on this matter. He instructed his governor: “Keep away from you those of your kinsmen who may not be well-disposed to you, and those who may have bad influence on your administration. Do not give any plot of land to them, and do not let them take possession of anything of the public property.” (Nahj al-Balagha). This injunction provides a clear and uncompromising guide for public servants to root out nepotism and favouritism from the very beginning of their administration.
Critical Analysis: A Comparative Study with the Civil Service of Pakistan
While the Islamic framework provides a clear and idealistic model for public service, its application in modern states, particularly in Pakistan, faces significant challenges. The Pakistani civil service, a legacy of colonial rule, operates on a different set of principles, often leading to a stark gap between the Islamic ideals and the administrative reality.
The Gap Between Theory and Practice
The principles of Adl, Amanah, and Mas'uliyah stand in sharp contrast to the pervasive issues of corruption, red-tapism, and political interference in Pakistan's bureaucracy. Instead of being a servant of the people, a civil servant in Pakistan is often perceived as a member of an elite class, disconnected from the struggles of the common man. The colonial-era structures of authority and privilege, rather than the Islamic ideals of humility and service, often define the civil servant's mindset. The lack of robust accountability mechanisms and the pervasive culture of impunity mean that a civil servant is often held accountable to their political master rather than to the people or a higher moral authority. This leads to a breakdown of public trust and undermines the very foundations of good governance.
Challenges and Their Islamic Solutions
Corruption and Nepotism: Widespread corruption and the appointment of unqualified individuals through connections erode public institutions.
Islamic Solution: The Islamic principle of Amanah and the strict meritocracy espoused by the Prophet (PBUH) and the Caliphs offer a clear solution. Reinstating a system where a position is a divine trust for which one will be questioned, and where appointments are based solely on merit and competence, can be a powerful deterrent.
Lack of Accountability: The absence of effective checks and balances allows civil servants to operate with impunity.
Islamic Solution: The dual accountability to Allah and the people, as exemplified by Hazrat Umar's (RA) Hisbah system, can serve as a model for reform. Creating a culture of transparency and public accountability, where citizens have the right to question their officials, can restore public trust.
Red-tapism and Inefficiency: The complex, hierarchical bureaucracy often hinders the efficient delivery of services.
Islamic Solution: The principle of service (Khidmah) and the emphasis on humility and responsiveness, as shown in the lives of the Caliphs, offer a way to restructure the bureaucracy to be more citizen-centric. A civil servant who views their role as a service will be more likely to find creative solutions to problems rather than being bound by rigid procedures.
Conclusion
The responsibilities of civil servants in Islam are not a mere set of rules but a comprehensive ethical framework for good governance. Built on the foundational principles of justice, trust, accountability, and consultation, this framework provides a timeless guide for public officials. The examples from the lives of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) and the Rightly Guided Caliphs serve as a practical demonstration of how these principles can be implemented to create a just, prosperous, and peaceful society. In the context of modern states like Pakistan, where a crisis of governance plagues the civil service, these Islamic teachings offer a powerful and much-needed antidote. By returning to these core principles, civil servants can transform their role from that of a privileged elite to a true servant of the people, thereby fulfilling their sacred trust and contributing to the welfare of their nation.
Possible CSS/PMS Exam Questions
Based on the article, here are some possible exam questions for Islamic Studies:
1. "The ruler is a guardian over his subjects and is responsible for them." Elaborate on the concept of Mas'uliyah (Accountability) in Islam and discuss how it can be applied to reform the modern civil service in Pakistan.
2. Highlight the foundational principles of public administration in Islam. Explain, with reference to the Qur’an and Sunnah, how the principles of justice (Adl) and trust (Amanah) are interdependent for effective governance.
3. Discuss the role of a civil servant in Islam as a custodian of public funds. Provide examples from the lives of the Rightly Guided Caliphs to illustrate the principles of financial prudence and fiscal transparency.
4. Analyze the concept of meritocracy in Islam with reference to the appointment of public officials. How can the Islamic perspective on competence and integrity help to combat nepotism and corruption in a modern state?
5. "The leader of the people is their servant." Explain the importance of humility and public service (Khidmah) for a civil servant in Islam. How can these qualities lead to a more compassionate and responsive bureaucracy?
6. Critically analyse the challenges of corruption, inefficiency, and red-tapism in Pakistan's civil service. How can the Islamic framework of public administration provide a sustainable solution to these problems?
7. How does the principle of Shura (Consultation) guide a civil servant's decision-making process? Discuss its significance in fostering an inclusive and effective administration.
8. "Protection of the Rights and Welfare of All Citizens" is a key responsibility. Discuss how Islamic teachings and historical examples from the Rightly Guided Caliphs guarantee the rights of non-Muslim citizens.
9. Critically evaluate the discrepancy between the Islamic ideal of a civil servant as a "servant of the people" and the colonial-era legacy of a hierarchical and elite-oriented bureaucracy in Pakistan.
10. Explain the concepts of Amanah (Trust) and Mas'uliyah (Accountability) as the ethical foundation for public service in Islam. How do these principles serve as a powerful deterrent against corruption?
