The well-being and future of a nation are inextricably linked to the welfare and development of its children. When children come into conflict with the law, the response of the state through its Juvenile Justice System (JJS) becomes a critical indicator of its commitment to human rights, social justice, and enlightened governance. Pakistan, as a signatory to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and with its own constitutional safeguards, has made legislative strides, notably with the enactment of the Juvenile Justice System Act (JJSA) 2018. This editorial seeks to dissect the architecture and aspirations of Pakistan's JJS, illuminate the profound challenges undermining its efficacy, and advocate for a concerted, multi-stakeholder reform agenda to transform it into a system that genuinely shields and nurtures the nation's future.
Follow Cssprepforum WhatsApp Channel: Pakistan’s Largest CSS, PMS Prep Community updated
Led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Cssprepforum helps 70,000+ aspirants monthly with top-tier CSS/PMS content. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for solved past papers, expert articles, and free study resources shared by qualifiers and high scorers.
Understanding Pakistan's Juvenile Justice System
Pakistan's Juvenile Justice System is a legal framework aimed at addressing the needs of children under the age of eighteen who come into conflict with the law. Ostensibly and clearly, this system emphasizes rehabilitation over punishment, focusing on the protection of children's rights and their reintegration into society. The Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018, serves as the cornerstone of this framework, establishing specialized courts and procedures to ensure that minors are treated with dignity and provided with opportunities for education and personal development. The system seeks to create a supportive environment that fosters the well-being of young offenders, recognizing their potential for reform and the importance of safeguarding their future.
Components Of Juvenile Justice System
- The Police
- The Prosecution
- The Defense Lawyer
- The Juvenile Court
- The Juvenile Justice Committee
- The Probation Officer Rehabilitation Center + Observation homes
The Chasm Between Law and Lived Reality: Prevailing Challenges
1.Inconsistent Implementation of Juvenile Justice Laws
One of the major challenges faced by Pakistan’s Juvenile Justice System (JJS) is the poor implementation of laws designed to protect juvenile offenders. Despite the Juvenile Justice System Act (JJSA), 2018, which mandates specialized courts, rehabilitation centers, and legal aid, enforcement remains weak. According to a report by the Research Society of International Law (RSIL), “The lack of proper infrastructure and trained personnel significantly hampers the effectiveness of the JJSA, leaving many children vulnerable to systemic failures.” In this regard, many juveniles are still processed through adult courts or detained with hardened criminals, exposing them to abuse and negative influences. Hence, the implementation of juvenile justice laws is crucial for protecting Pakistan’s vulnerable children.
2. Lack Of Resources Affecting JJS in Pakistan
Next, many districts lack dedicated juvenile courts, observation homes, and rehabilitation centers, often processing juveniles through adult courts or detaining them with criminals, risking abuse and negative influences. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) report, “Insufficient facilities and trained personnel remain a significant barrier to juvenile justice reform.” Illustratively, facilities that do exist are typically under-resourced and poorly maintained, with a shortage of trained social workers, psychologists, and probation officers vital for rehabilitation. Thus, this staffing gap results in limited implementation of social inquiry reports and diversion programs.
3. Lack of Reliable Age Determination in Pakistan
Moving forward, another challenge faced by the juvenile justice system in Pakistan is the lack of accurate age determination. Due to low birth registration rates, especially in rural and marginalized communities, many children’s ages remain uncertified. According to the United Nations International Children's Emergency Fund (UNICEF) report “Accurate age verification is fundamental to safeguarding the rights of children within the juvenile justice system.” Furthermore, this uncertainty often leads to minors being tried and detained as adults, exposing them to harsher treatment and increasing the risk of abuse. Therefore, without reliable age assessment, the system struggles to ensure that minors receive appropriate protections and rehabilitative services.
Forging a Future of Hope: Essential Reforms for Juvenile Justice
1. Strengthening Juvenile Justice Implementation in Pakistan
First, to ensure effective implementation of juvenile justice laws in Pakistan, systemic reforms are essential. The Juvenile Justice System Act (JJSA), 2018 mandates specialized courts and rehabilitation centers for juvenile in the state. As Janet Reno quoted that “The effective way to reduce and prevent juvenile crime is to balance enforcement measures with targeted, effective, and intervention initiatives.” Additionally, stronger inter-agency coordination among law enforcement, judiciary, and welfare departments is needed for seamless execution. Therefore, implementation of law in the country should play a crucial role in the strengthening of JJS.
2. Reforming Rehabilitation Center and Support Training
Second, transforming Pakistan’s JJS into a rehabilitative system requires committed reforms and political will. In this context, key priorities include fully implementing the JJSA 2018, establishing child-friendly courts, observation homes, and rehabilitative centers with education and psychosocial support. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) report 2023, “Sustainable reform depends on comprehensive infrastructure, trained personnel, and a child-centered approach to juvenile justice.” Moreover, adequate recruitment and training of specialized staff, including judges, police, social workers, and psychologists are vital. Hence, standardized training on child rights and trauma-informed care should be mandatory.
Join Sir Kazim’s Extensive CSS/PMS English Course Starting July 7
Sir Kazim's CSS/PMS English Essay & Precis course starts July 7 at 8 p.m. Only 60 seats; apply early! Submit a 200-word paragraph to secure your spot. Fee: Rs. 15,000/month.
3. Strengthening Diversionary Mechanisms and Community-Based Initiatives in JJS
Third, enhancing diversionary mechanisms and community-based initiatives is vital for juvenile justice reform in the country. In this regard, fully empowering Juvenile Justice Committees with resources to implement programs, like victim-offender mediation, restorative justice, and community service is essential. According to a report by the Khyber Journal of Public Policy, “Legal awareness are key to addressing systemic deficiencies and ensuring juveniles receive proper legal protection.” Likewise, robust legal aid services, backed by state funding should be accessible to juveniles. Additionally, addressing root causes requires social welfare, child protection, and family support programs. Thus, investing in research and data collection, including recidivism tracking is crucial for evidence-based policies.
Conclusively, the state of Pakistan's Juvenile Justice System is a litmus test of its commitment to its most vulnerable citizens and its vision for the future. While the JJSA 2018 provides a commendable legal blueprint, its potential can only be realized through dedicated implementation, sustained investment, and a fundamental shift in mindset from punishment to protection and rehabilitation. Furthermore, the challenges are significant, ranging from infrastructural deficits and capacity gaps to deeply ingrained societal attitudes. However, they are not insurmountable. A collaborative approach involving the government, judiciary, law enforcement agencies, civil society organizations, academia, and the community at large is imperative.
