Question Breakdown
The question is two-fold. The first part demands a detailed exposition of the rights Islam grants to women in various domains such as social, legal, spiritual, and economic life. The second part requires a comparative analysis of how women’s rights in Islam differ or align with those in other religions like Christianity, Judaism, and Hinduism. The answer must be structured to highlight Islam’s approach while offering specific comparative instances from religious scriptures or traditions.
Outline
- Introduction
- Spiritual and Religious Rights of Women
- A. Women’s connection with the Creator in Islam
- B. Comparative view: Christianity, Judaism, and Hinduism
- Legal and Marital Rights
- A. Consent in marriage and right to divorce
- B. Inheritance and property ownership
- C. Comparative perspective with other religions
- Educational and Intellectual Rights
- Economic and Property Rights
- Social Dignity and Role of Women
- Misconceptions about Women in Islam
- Critical Analysis
- Conclusion
Follow CPF WhatsApp Channel for Daily Exam Updates
Led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Cssprepforum helps 70,000+ aspirants monthly with top-tier CSS/PMS content. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for solved past papers, expert articles, and free study resources shared by qualifiers and high scorers.
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The dignity of women has been the subject of theological, social, and legal debate in all major world religions. While historical interpretations often favored patriarchal structures, Islam emerged with a clear, systematic, and balanced framework that upheld the dignity and rights of women as full human beings and moral agents. In comparison, other religious traditions, such as Christianity, Judaism, and Hinduism, have reflected a mix of reverence and repression in the way they treat women’s status in sacred texts and law.
Spiritual and Religious Rights of Women
Islamic teachings affirm that both men and women are equal in their spiritual accountability before Allah. Women are addressed directly in the Qur’an, and their capacity to earn reward or punishment is equal to that of men. “Whoever does righteous deeds, whether male or female, while being a believer, We will surely cause them to live a good life.” (Surah An-Nahl 16:97)
In contrast, certain Christian doctrines, especially early Church teachings, regarded women as spiritually inferior or responsible for original sin, based on interpretations of the Genesis narrative. In Judaism, women are exempt from many religious obligations and their spiritual participation is limited in synagogue life. Hinduism assigns spiritual purity to women in some cases but also subjects them to rigid purity laws that restrict temple entry during certain periods.
Legal and Marital Rights
Islam emphasizes the importance of a woman’s consent in marriage, the right to Mahr (dowry), and grants her the right to initiate divorce through Khula. Women also have the right to inherit from their relatives and to own and manage their property independently. “Men shall have a share of what the parents and relatives leave, and women shall have a share of what the parents and relatives leave…” (Surah An-Nisa 4:7)
In contrast, in traditional Christian canon law, divorce was largely forbidden, and women had limited legal autonomy. Jewish law allows divorce but requires the husband to issue a Get (divorce document), often placing women in vulnerable positions. In Hinduism, marriage was considered a sacrament, and divorce was socially and religiously discouraged, often leaving women in oppressive marital situations without recourse.
Educational and Intellectual Rights
The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) declared that the pursuit of knowledge is obligatory for every Muslim, male and female. Women were scholars, transmitters of Hadith, and contributors to intellectual life throughout Islamic history. Aisha (RA), the wife of the Prophet, narrated over 2000 Hadiths and was a leading authority in Islamic jurisprudence. In contrast, women's access to religious scholarship in Christianity and Judaism was historically limited. Monasticism allowed women's education in specific settings, but leadership roles remained exclusively male. In Hinduism, sacred texts such as the Vedas were traditionally restricted to male Brahmins, and female education was not universally encouraged.
CSS Solved Islamiat Past Papers from 2010 to Date by Miss Ayesha Irfan
Gain unmatched conceptual clarity with CSS Solved Islamiat (2010 – To Date) by Miss Ayesha Irfan, the definitive guide to mastering Islamiat for CSS with precision, insight, and unwavering confidence!
Economic and Property Rights
Islamic law guarantees women full economic rights, including the right to earn, own, and invest money. A woman’s wealth is solely hers, and she is not obliged to spend on the household, which remains the husband’s responsibility. “And do not consume one another’s wealth unjustly…” (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:188)
In pre-Islamic Arabia, women had no inheritance rights; Islam revolutionized this. In contrast, Christian Europe only recognized women’s property rights after centuries of legal reform. Hindu widows historically could not inherit property, and the system of dowry, though cultural, became a means of exploitation. Jewish law granted limited rights of inheritance to daughters only when no sons existed.
Social Dignity and Role of Women
Islam gave women an honorable status as mothers, daughters, wives, and citizens. The Prophet (PBUH) said, “Paradise lies under the feet of your mother.” (Sunan An-Nasa’i) Women actively participated in society, business, politics, and even in battles. This contrasts with the often marginal and subservient roles prescribed to women in other traditions, where asceticism, celibacy, or strict gender roles were glorified.
Misconceptions about Women in Islam
Despite the clear rights granted to women in Islam, misconceptions persist due to cultural practices, patriarchal misinterpretations, and a lack of awareness. Practices like forced marriages, denial of education, and veiling by compulsion are cultural deviations, not Islamic mandates. In fact, these practices exist across many cultures and religions but are often wrongly attributed exclusively to Islam.
Critical Analysis
Islam granted women unparalleled rights at a time when they were largely denied basic humanity in other societies. While other religions did offer spiritual or symbolic reverence to women, they often denied them equal participation in legal, social, or economic domains. The Islamic model, however, while not free from misuse by followers, stands out for its holistic and enduring framework of rights. The problem today is not with Islam, but with its misapplication or neglect in practice. Comparative religious analysis reveals that Islam’s treatment of women was, and remains, revolutionary and reformative.
Conclusion
Women’s rights in Islam are deeply rooted in divine guidance and Prophetic practice. From spiritual equality to legal independence, Islam’s framework was centuries ahead of many societies. While other religions offered partial or symbolic rights, Islam institutionalized justice for women in every realm of life. A fair comparison highlights that Islam recognizes the dignity of women not as a concession but as a divine right. Implementing these rights in spirit and practice remains the key to uplifting women in Muslim societies today.
